A. THE DIFFERENCES
- Trusts are Common Law solutions. Foundations are of origin Civil Law Solutions. They are designed to achieve the same solutions for international estate planning such as family succession, asset protection, family governance, avoidance of the need for Wills and Probate and legal mitigation of taxation.
- Foundations are registered legal entities like a company. Trusts are largely unregistered legal entities. Therefore, Foundations own their assets, like a company, while the Trustee of a Trust hold and look after the assets of a Trust for the Beneficiaries of the Trust.
- Foundations are governed by a Charter and Articles or Rules, which are similar to the Memorandum and Articles of a company. A Trust is governed by a Trust Deed. It may be possible to vary both, depending upon the governing law and the terms of the Charter and Articles or Rules and the terms of the Trust Deed. In a world of constant change, flexibility through the exercise of variation of a Trust or Foundation is becoming ever more important.
- The Trustee manages and controls a Trust, subject to checks and balances and a Foundation is managed and controlled by a Council, which is like a Board of Directors of a company, and there may be checks and balances to this too.
- A Foundation, unlike a company, has no shareholders and has to be for a purpose and that purpose can also include people as Beneficiaries, although such people may not be beneficially entitled to anything unless the Council decides that any one or more of them shall benefit. Trusts are primarily for Beneficiaries and can include charities or charitable purposes and, if the governing law permits, may also be for non-charitable purposes.
- A Trust Deed frequently provides for a Protector who, depending on the powers provided to the Protector, may remove and appoint the Trustee and Beneficiaries or whose consent may be needed by the Trustee for those or other powers. A Foundation may provide for a Guardian (or a similar person) with similar sorts of powers and perhaps a Supervisory Person (or a similar person) to supervise the Council.
- People can have powers reserved to them in a Trust Deed and the extent of this depends upon the governing law. If a Settlor, who is the creator of a Trust, reserves too much power and control, then there will be no Trust but rather a nominee arrangement by the Trustee for the Settlor. Again, depending upon the extent of the governing law of a Foundation, there may be powers reserved to the Founder, who is the person who creates a Foundation, or indeed to others and it may be possible for such persons to assign their powers.
- How long a Trust may last depends upon the governing law of the Trust. Some laws permit perpetual Trusts and some do not. There will usually be a power for the Trustee to at least shorten a Trust Period. a Foundation, like a company, will continue until it is liquidated or there may be power in the Charter and Articles or Rules for it last for a stated period to be determined sooner than liquidation.
- It should be possible to change the Trustee and/or the governing law of a Trust. Unless a jurisdiction provides for a specific form of Trust, which must have a Trustee in the same jurisdiction, the Trustee can usually be from a separate jurisdiction to the jurisdiction, the law of which governs the Trust. Since a Foundation is a registered legal entity, it depends upon its governing law as to whether or not is can be redomiciled to be governed by the law of another jurisdiction.
- When creating a Trust or a Foundation and thereafter, it will be necessary to see if there are tax exemptions which apply to it by reference to its governing law. Sometimes, such exemptions may apply to specific forms of Trust, such as a Foreign Grantor Trust for the USA or a Granny Trust for Canada or exempt foreign Trusts under, say, the laws of New Zealand, Samoa or Singapore.
- If there are relevant persons tax resident in, or assets situated in, a particular jurisdiction, does that jurisdiction (being governed by Common Law or Civil law) understand or cater for Trusts and/or Foundations? This is an important factorthat you, as the Settlor of a Trust or the Founder of a Foundation, must consider, ideally with the advice and guidance of your professional advisor, who specialises in this area of trust/foundation and tax law.