Skip to content

Protecting Your Assets: More Than Just Wealth Preservation

A family preparing sailboats by the water

INTRODUCTION:

How can you use solutions for international estate planning to protect your assets and from what?

The answer is that Trusts can be used to protect your assets from claims by your creditors, claims made in accordance with foreign succession laws and marital claims. There is also the possibility of working to create ongoing family harmony to prevent family discord and claims arising between family members.

The objective of this Article is to look at each of these lines of protection.

It also has to be realised at the start that, if you hold assets situated in a jurisdiction where the government or the law determines that such assets should be confiscated, then there is unlikely to be recourse available…..

ASSET PROTECTION FROM CREDITORS:

This section of the Article focuses on how a Trust, which you create, can be used to protect the assets, which you transfer to the Trustees of that Trust, from claims by your creditors.

In general, the factors, which are relevant to establishment of asset protection from your creditors by the use of a Trust of which you are the Settlor/creator, are as follows:

If the principal intention of the creation of the Trust, or the transfer of assets to it, was to defraud creditors of the Settlor (you), and rendered the Settlor insolvent, then the property transferred is not protected.

If the transfer of property takes place before the creditor’s cause of action arises, there can be protection.

If the transfer takes place after a stated period of years before the creditor’s cause of action arose, the property transferred will be protected.

The question of how long that period should be depends on the legislation of the jurisdiction of the governing law of the Trust.

There is potential danger in looking for instant success. In that respect, two cases relating to The Cook Islands should be noted as follows:

Re. XYZ Irrevocable Trust (“the Anderson Case”) [1999 CKHC 5].

South Orange Grove Association and Others v Orange Grove Partners and Others [1995 CKHC 1 208].

Perhaps a short but reasonable period of time is a sensible choice and in that respect there is the example of 2 years under the laws of Labuan and Samoa.

PROTECTION FROM CLAIMS UNDER FOREIGN SUCCESSION LAWS:

Quite simply, a foreign Discretionary Trust (holding foreign assets) can be used to prevent claims under, for example, La Reserve Hereditaire in France, forced heirship laws in Argentina and Muslim Sharia Law.

PROTECTION FROM MARITAL CLAIMS:

The use of Pre-Nuptial Agreements and of Post-Nuptial Agreements can, of course, play their part in preventing claims.

Otherwise, the questions to be asked and actions to be taken are generally as follows:

Are you, the Settlor of the Trust, subject to a matrimonial property regime, such as that in China, which would require the prior consent of your spouse to the transfer of the property into the trust?

Can the Trust be construed as a “nuptial settlement”? The question is whether there is a sufficient connection between the Trust and the marriage. This is a matter of evolving case law.

Has property been transferred to a family company in such a way that the “corporate veil” should be pierced as an extension of a nuptial settlement? Examples of this can be found in the following cases:

Prest v Petrodel Resources Limited & Others [2013 UKSC 34] – See also

DR v GR and Others [2013 EWHC 1196]

Chai v Peng & Others [2017 EWHC 792]

Ways to seek to prevent a nuptial settlement are as follows:

If the Trust has a wide class of Beneficiaries, this may make it harder to argue that it is associated with any particular marriage.

The wide class of Beneficiaries should not include any spouse or prospective spouse of any of the Beneficiaries but should include future generations of the family. Indeed the terms of the Trust can exclude spouses of Beneficiaries from benefit.

Any Letter of Wishes, which you, as Settlor of the Trust, will give to the Trustees of the Trust needs to be drafted with great care to show that it is not your wish or intention that any spouse of a member of your family should benefit.

A potentially more dangerous question is whether the Trust is a “financial resource” available to a spouse of a member of the family, if he or she makes a claim. The answer to this question is determined by “the likelihood test”, which is concerned with the answers to the following 2 questions:

  1. What is the likelihood of the income or capital of the Trust Fund of the Trust being paid, applied, transferred or appointed to or for the benefit of any Beneficiary who is a spouse?
  2. If the Beneficiary, who is a spouse, asks the Trustees of the Trust for financial assistance, would the Trustees oblige?

Ways to seek to prevent the likelihood test applying are as follows:-

  1. the content of the trust and the Letter of Wishes need to show that the purpose of the trust is truly dynastic;
  2. the relationship between the Trustees and the Beneficiary, who is a spouse, needs to show the history of distributions and that the Trustees exercise their discretions without any controlling influence from that Beneficiary’s spouse; and
  3. ring-fencing a fund for the Beneficiary, who is a spouse, and leaving the remainder of the Trust Fund free from a claim of being a financial resource, will be helpful, provided it is properly forward planned.

Once again, all this shows an increasing need for Pre-Nuptial Agreements and, if necessary, Post-Nuptial Agreements.

FAMILY CHARTER:

A Family Charter is a detailed document setting out the family values and intentions which it is intended that the family will maintain.

The provisions can be very detailed and can cover many aspects from family life to investments to family business. The intention will be to provide for a Family Council which will meet and discuss all such matters and then decide issues as necessary.

With wealthy families, it is disturbing to see the increase of family discord and claims, which the proper use of a Family Charter and a Family Council will seek to avoid.

Another Article will cover the aspect of Family Offices in detail.

Talk to Us

Don’t hesitate to get in touch. We look forward to hearing from you.

Michael Shue: +64 (0)21 803 788
Claudia Shan: +64 (0)223 798 086

Tectonic Trust Enquiry